Recruiting | 15Min Read

What is the Executive Search Process? | Complete Guide

Written by
What Have We Covered?

Finding a shark in the vast ocean might be simple, but finding the right executive is certainly a tough task. Right?

It’s just not about finding the person for the role; it's about finding the leader who aligns with your company goals. 

That’s the most difficult part of the executive search.

But what if you get the search process that hijacks the best C-level talent, VP or director?

Sound interesting, right?

It’s an Executive search process.

It’s a specialised approach to finding the best of the best, the cream of the crop, the talent that will take your company to the next level. 

Top-tier executives who are currently excelling in their fields, not just actively looking for a job.

But hey, it's not all sunshine and rainbows. Navigating the waters of executive search can be tricky, especially with limited talent in the market. 

That's where this blog comes to the rescue. 

Help you navigate the twists and turns of the executive search process, leaving no page unturned until you find the perfect executive for your squad.

So what are you waiting for? 

Let's kickstart this journey and find your next leader. Get ready to witness the power of the executive search process in action. 

Ready to find a leader who makes your team better? Let's make it happen.

What is the Executive Search Process? 

Executive search is the process where you recruit talent for C-level positions, which include CEO, CFO, COO, CTO, president, vice president, and other senior management roles. 

Recruiting Executives is difficult. But why?

Because most executives are gonna be passive executives. Who isn’t necessarily looking to make a change? So, posting a generic job description online won’t help you to find them.  

Now you know that to find them, you need a unique search process, not a typical recruitment process.

Like in vast, you can find fish by traditional methods, but to find the pearl, you need a unique technique and process.   

Executive search firms generally operate on a retained basis. This means that they are paid a fee upfront by the client's company for conducting the search.

Where on a contingency basis, they only get paid if an executive is hired. 

This allows the executive search firm to conduct a more thorough and comprehensive search and to focus on finding the best possible executives for the position rather than simply filling the role as quickly as possible.

How Do You Start an Executive Search Process?

Executive search processes are similar to regular recruitment processes. But the target candidates are C-level executives. 

So, let’s learn these steps of this executive search process and find the best one.

1. Understand Your Client’s Need

A. In-depth consultation with the client 

Before you start this process, have a coffee meeting with the client. To understand the client's unique executive recruitment challenges and the specifics of the leadership role they're looking to fill. 

Once you have a clear picture, then you can easily tailor your search to their needs and expectations.

B. Analyse company culture & identify talent’s characteristics 

In an executive search, executives who fit with company culture and align with your client’s goal are more important.

Many executives believe that a strong culture is vital for business success. 

They are the ones who will lead their teams and company, so having the same goal will boost their company's growth and success. First, you need to understand the company's values, work environment, and leadership expectations to find that executive.

C. Discussing the position's requirements 

Discuss the requirements for that position with your clients, such as what qualifications, experience, and desired skills they want. So, accordingly, you only put forward executives who are well-matched to the role and requirements.

D. Clarifying the timeline and budget for the search 

Have an idea of within what time they want talent. Have a clear timeline from your client. Knowing their recruitment budget before is also a crucial part of the process.  So you can plan your search accordingly and keep the client informed of progress.

2. Build a Winning Executive Search Strategy

By this point, you know your clients’ needs and are ready to create a winning strategy. Developing a winning search strategy is like building a strong foundation for a house. 

It's the blueprint that guides the entire search project. It makes sure that everyone involved is on the same page and working towards the similar goal. 

A well-crafted executive recruitment strategy can help you find qualified executives faster and avoid potential roadblocks.

To create a winning search strategy, you'll need to start with a clear job description that outlines the main responsibilities and requirements of the role.  

This is like the framework of the house, providing a basic structure around which everything else will be built. 

Once you have a solid job description, you can start to provide more details of your search strategy, including the research criteria, target company list, logistics and expectations. 

Decide your research criteria, such as having specific qualifications and experience that you're looking for in executives. It will help you narrow down your search to the most promising executives. Also, create a list of target companies.

Focus your efforts and resources on the targeted area. It's the list of companies and industries that you'll target in your executive search process. 

Finally, to ensure that your executive search strategy is on track, you'll want to use benchmark profiles to calibrate your search and get feedback from your client. 

This is like conducting a final inspection of the house before it's complete, ensuring that everything is up to code and that the client is satisfied with the results.

In layman's language, a benchmark profile means you compare future executives' profiles with your ideal executive. By using benchmark profiles, you can make any necessary adjustments to your search strategy.

Checklist for executive search strategy

3. Conduct the Research

Conducting research for an executive search is like developing the soil before planting seeds in a garden. 

It's a crucial step that requires careful planning and implementation to ensure the best possible outcome. 

Just as a gardener requires the right tools and a clear understanding of what they're growing, a researcher needs a well-defined recruitment strategy and the right resources to find the best executives.

First, you should start by using what you already have. This means leveraging your existing network and database. Look for people who match the research criteria and are connected to the target companies. 

These are your potential executives who are more likely to respond to your outreach because they already have a connection with you.

If this does not work, go for the second step. For that, you should expand your search to include 'sources'. 

These are people who may not be an exact fit for the role, but they might know someone who is. 

They are like signboard on road who can point you in the right direction, guiding you towards the person who has exactly what you need. 

Once you've exhausted your own resources, then it's time to look further afield. This could mean searching online platforms like LinkedIn. 

However, these executives are passive executives, and they don't know you, so they might not respond to your outreach. So, it's important to approach them in the right way and to keep track of where each executive came from.

Finally, just as an architect keeps a blueprint of every detail of a building, you should keep clear records of your research. 

Use tools like Research Criteria Scorecards to track your progress and showcase your results. This not only helps you stay organised but also demonstrates your competence and thoroughness to your clients or stakeholders.

Research criteria score card

Now the research is complete is time to do the real work and go out for hunt to find your ideal executive.

4. Start Executive Outreach 

Outreach is like the first hello between an executive and a potential job opportunity. 

It's not just about sending a mass email to everyone in your database; rather, it's about starting a conversation, building a personal connection, and sending personalised mail.

The best executives for executive roles are usually already employed and not actively looking, so outreach is the key to reaching them and sparking their interest.

So, make sure that your job description is strong enough to spark their interest.

Think of outreach as fishing, where each potential executive is a fish in the sea. Your research is the bait, carefully designed to attract only sharks out of other fishes. So, the success of your outreach will depend on the quality of your research.

You need to understand what factors are important to the executives and what things will attract them. What things are lacking in their current job that you’ll provide them? What are they looking for in a new opportunity? 

This will help you tailor your outreach, and you can offer what they are lacking.

Executive-level talent wants to be approached by headhunters. 

The goal of outreach is to connect with executives who not only look good on paper but are also a good fit for the role and the company. 

It's not just about selling the opportunity to the executive but also about selling the executive to the client. You need to know more than just where the executive went to school or what their current job is. 

Outreach is the initial step in building a relationship with the executive and understanding who they are and what they can bring to the table. 

Improving your research strategy is the best way to improve your outreach and increase your chances of success in the executive search process.

5. Executive Assessment and Evaluation 

Assessment step of the executive search process that works as a bridge between the research and decision-making process.

This process involves a thorough assessment of the candidate's skills, experiences, and cultural fit, determining whether they truly align with the job requirements and the client's company culture. 

This stage requires a deep conversation and a thorough evaluation of the executives, as only a small percentage of them will make it to this point.

In the assessment stage, organisations must delve deep into the executives' abilities and potential red flags. 

This involves sharing detailed reports and observations with the client. The goal is to ensure that the client has all the necessary information to make an informed decision.

This includes sharing background information, framing expectations, and communicating any potential red flags. 

Think of it as a chef presenting a dish to a food critic, where the chef explains the ingredients, the cooking process, and the inspiration behind the dish. 

In the same way, the executive search firm should present the candidate to the client, providing a clear picture of the executive's abilities and how they would fit within the company.

Status reports and Candidate Assessment Reports (CARs) are essential tools in this stage. They allow you to keep the client updated on the progress of the executive search process and to provide a comprehensive write-up of everything uncovered about the finalists. 

The CAR is like a report card for the candidate, highlighting their strengths, weaknesses, and the search firm's final recommendations.

It's important to remember that the search firm's role is not to aggressively sell an executive but to present the information and remove any obstacles for a productive conversation so both parties can make the best decision.

6. Shortlist Presentation and Interview Facilitation

After doing all these steps in the executive search process, now it’s time to show off.  Present a curated list of top executives to your client. 

This should include detailed profiles of each executive, highlighting their strengths, relevant experience, and potential fit within the organisation. 

Also, an assessment summary should be provided to give the client a clear understanding of how each executive was evaluated. To do this, you have to arrange an interview with your clients and executives. 

Coordinate with both to arrange a suitable time for the interviews. Provide executives with insights into the company culture, interview format, and key stakeholders they will be interacting with.  

This will help them prepare and present themselves in the best possible manner. 

Handle all the interview logistics, including interview scheduling, travel arrangements (if necessary), and virtual meeting setups require during the executive search process. 

Conduct comprehensive interviews with the most promising executives. This could include behavioural questions, situational questions, and competency-based questions to thoroughly assess their skills and suitability for the role. 

Provide feedback to the client based on the interviews conducted. If necessary, arrange for second-round interviews with the client's team. After each round of interviews, gather feedback from both the client and the executives. 

This will help in making informed decisions and improving the overall process.

7. Reference Checks and Background Verification

Before you start, make sure that the executives have given their consent for the background check and reference verification.  

We can't just go in blindly!

Once we get the green light, we can start it.

Reach out to the references given by the applicants. Prepare a set of questions to gather information about the executive's skills, abilities, work ethic, nature, Leadership and management style, resilience, and behaviour with team members. 

Some questions could include:

  • What was the executive's role and responsibilities?
  • How would you describe their performance?
  • What are their key strengths and areas for improvement?
  • Would you rehire them if given a chance?
  • Were they good at leading the team?

After gathering information from past companies, it's time to verify their background, including their educational qualifications, work history, and any other relevant information. 

Now, after this, you are piled up with so many lintels, so what you’ll do is compile that into a clear and concise report for every single executive.

So your client can easily able to digest that information.

Share these reports with the client. Discuss the findings with them and answer any questions they might have. This will help them make an informed decision about the executive.

Make sure they are happy with what you have found and find the right treasure for your client's needs!

8. Negotiation & Offer Management

This step of the executive search recruitment process is more about how effectively you can communicate your offer with the executive. By doing this, you can secure top executives.

Before negotiation and offer, the selection comes before the executive search process.

For selection, you have to gather feedback from clients and ensure that you are on the same page. This feedback helps you to understand their preference and concerns, which is very crucial in the end, as they are the ones who will hire.

Once the selection process has been done, The next step is negotiation. For that, you, as the neutral third party, let them have an open room discussion between your client and the executive.

You can attract them by offering alluring compensation. For compensation, you can also directly ask executives what they want. Now, as a third party, your task is to boil down to setting expectations.

Note that many states have laws around what you can and can’t ask an executive, particularly around compensation. Make sure you’re well-versed in the laws that apply in your area.

The main aim behind this negotiation is that it should be a win-win for both parties, and once the executives are onboard, they should not feel dissatisfied.

The next step is to draft an offer, which requires considering many things.

Such as do market research, compensation trends and competitor data to ensure the offered package is competitive.

This might include sign-on bonuses, performance incentives, stock options, or benefits packages tailored to the executive's needs.

Based on this, create an offer later that they can't say no to. Now, it’s time to send them an offer to let them know they got selected.

Congratulations, you conducted an executive search process and got your next top executive. 

9. Executive Onboarding

Well, onboarding process support is a crucial part of the executive search process that doesn't end once an executive has been hired. 

It's about ensuring that the new executive settles into their role and the organisation smoothly and effectively.

In this step of the executive search process, you provide the new executive with information about the company culture, key personnel, and strategic objectives or facilitate meetings and introductions.

Make sure that the new executive and your client are satisfied with the placement. They must get a positive experience during your executive search process. 

The ultimate goal of onboarding support is to ensure the successful integration of the new executive into the organisation. 

10. Post-Placement Follow-up 

Now that your founded executive has been placed follow up with both parties to check whether everything went well. Are they satisfied?

Another significant step of the executive search process is gathering feedback from both the client and the executive. 

It’ll help you to identify areas of strength, what went well, and what did not.

Lastly, it's important to mention the possibility of providing post-placement support to address any initial challenges.

In summary, post-placement follow-up involves maintaining contact with the client and the placed executive, providing necessary support, gathering feedback, and continuously refining strategies for future searches.

It's a vital step in ensuring a successful outcome for all parties involved.

Now, here your work is complete. 

Additionally, by conducting an executive recruiting process, you’ll get better day by day and grow your database. 

Also, develop and nurture your network over time.

Think of conducting a search like running a race. In order to win, you need to keep up your speed and effort until you cross the finish line. 

The same is true for your firm's searches. If you stay focused and committed right up to the end, your firm will be in a stronger position and will achieve more success over time.

What is the Executive Search Process Timeline

Now, the main question is: how much time will be required to conduct this process? Here is the timeline for the whole executive search process so you'll get an idea about the time required to acquire your next bigshot.

Timeline for Executive Search Process

So, for this whole executive search process, the total Timeline is approximately 60-74 Days.

This timeline is a general guideline and can vary based on the complexity of the role, market conditions, and client-specific factors.

Strategic Advantages of the Executive Search Process

Let's focus on the strategic advantages specific to the executive search process itself. It enables you to secure top leadership talent effectively.

1. Targeted Search Strategy

This process makes sure that you focus like a sharpshooter on one target(hiring a top executive). The executive who not only has the required skills but also aligns with your culture and goals.

2. Strategic Talent Landscaping

For example, before you start playing chess, you study the board and understand the position of each piece. This will help you to make strategic decisions. This same goes for the executive search process. It provides insight into where the top executive is located, their availability, and how they can be approached, which helps you to make informed hiring decisions.

3. Leadership Qualities Assessment

The executive search process is not the normal recruitment process. It’s not only focused on technical skills; it delves into leadership qualities that are crucial for senior-level roles. It also includes visionary thinking, decision-making capabilities, and the ability to inspire and motivate teams at a strategic level  As a result, it only leads you to hire the best leader.

4. Confidentiality and Sensitivity

An Executive search process is conducted like a secret mission. It is designed with enhanced confidentiality. This helps you to keep executives' information private without risking their current job. 

5. Reduced Competition 

In this process, you only approach the passive executives, so they are less likely to be interviewing with multiple companies simultaneously. But for active job seekers, it’s common. This will reduce competition and may lead to a smoother executive search process.

6. Improved Retention

 In the executive search process, a executive is currently working in a very good and high position. So, they will only move for the right and best opportunities rather than simply out of necessity. Chances will be higher that they are likely to stay longer at a company, which ultimately improves your retention rate.

7. Risk Mitigation

Hiring for C-level positions comes with significant risks due to the impact these roles have on the organisation. The executive search process is designed to mitigate these risks through a thorough evaluation, background checks, and detailed assessments that assess more than just their resume.

So, to gain these advantages of the executive search process, you have to follow it precisely. By honing in on these key elements of this process, you can strategically position yourself to attract and secure leaders. A leader who will steer your business like a skilled captain, ensuring smooth sailing towards your long-term goals and culture.

What's the Role of Technology in the Executive Search Process? 

We just learned the whole executive search process. Now, it is important to understand how recruitment technology can help executive recruiters and headhunting firms manage the executive recruitment process. 

So, before implementing executive search software, let's understand the role of technology in the executive search process. 

1) Executive Sourcing & Screening Tools

Executive recruiters can leverage AI technology to quickly scan their databases to identify top executives or senior-level talent based on criteria like skills, experience, location, designation, and qualifications.  

2) Executive Relationship Management

The Recruiting CRM Systems help executive recruiters maintain high-level engagement. They can track interactions with potential executives, store profiles, and manage smooth communication to ensure a simplified hiring process for top-level executives. 

3) Virtual Interviewing and Executive Assessment Tools

By using interview scheduling and management software, you can conduct remote interviews and skills assessments to save time and money. It will help you to manage the interview management workflow. 

4) Integration with HR Systems

Executive search software can connect with HRIS to secure smooth data flow across all stages of the executive search process and update strategic planning.

5) Enhanced Engagement with Executives

The software for headhunters provides you with automated and personalised communication tools to keep executives informed and engaged, which will reduce drop-offs and improve the overall experience. 

6) Predictive Analytics

This feature predicts future executive search process needs and market trends that allow executive search firms to stay ahead in their strategies.

7) Data Security Features

This ensures the protection of sensitive and client information via robust security measures and compliance with international standards.

8) Advanced Analytics and Reporting

This feature provides insights into key recruitment metrics like time-to-fill and cost-per-hire, helping firms analyse trends and improve their strategies.

9) Executive Database Management

Your executive recruiters can simply segment and manage a complete executive database effectively. Executive headhunters can leverage this database to find the perfect executive using executive search software. 

If you want to employ the best executive search software, ensure the software provider offers the features mentioned above.

How Can iSmartRecruit Help You in Executive Search?

Want to hire C-level talent, VPs, and directors faster for your clients? 

Then, your search firm needs a proper executive search ATS to conduct the executive search process efficiently. 

But how did you do that? Well, it’s simple. Choose a software that is easy to use and highly scalable to meet your and your client's needs for an executive search process. 

That’s where iSmartRecruit comes into the picture. 

With iSmartRecruit, your executive search firm will receive a complete set of features to enhance your executive search process effectively. 

Our executive search platform utilises advanced AI technologies to automate and optimise various aspects of your executive recruitment. 

Its powerful executive database search capabilities can quickly scan your executive database to identify potential C-level talent, VPs or directors. 

As a result, it greatly reduces the time for executive recruiters spent on initial searches. 

With iSmartrecruit, your executive recruiters can engage in personalised communication to build trust and stay top-of-mind with the best executives. 

Your executive search and recruitment team can track engagement and monitor all communications, from emails to phone calls. 

Executive talent pool management gets easier. Using our executive search ATS, you can easily create and navigate a dedicated pool of C-level executives, VPs, and directors and segment it based on roles/designations. 

So, are you ready to simplify your end-to-end executive search process and hire the best executive for your clients? Then, request a demo by clicking the image below and see how iSmartRecruit helps you manage your workflow.

Simplify Your Executive Recruitment with iSmartRecruit!


Join Our Award-Winning AI Recruitment Software

Demos are a great, fast way to learn about iSmartRecruit.
Connect with us now to learn more!

30 minutes to explore the software.
30 minutes to explore the software.

Want to Simplify Your Executive Search?

Go with iSmartRecruit’s executive search software to streamline and manage end-to-end workflow and hire top executives.