Meet iSmartRecruit at TechExpo Gujarat 2026 | 27–29 November | Booth A83, Ahmedabad

Meet us at TechExpo Event

Get a Demo
Technology | 9Min Read

ATS Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Right ATS in 10 Steps

author

| Last Updated: Oct 28, 2026

What Have We Covered?

Selecting the right Applicant Tracking System (ATS) means defining your hiring requirements, agreeing on budget and timeline with stakeholders, shortlisting vendors, scoring them against a weighted checklist, testing the finalists through demos and trials, checking security and contract terms, and then planning implementation and data migration. This ATS buyer’s guide explains each step, lists the features and criteria to assess and includes 55 questions to ask vendors. It is written for corporate talent acquisition teams, recruitment agencies and executive search firms comparing ATS platforms.

TL;DR

  • Define your requirements, budget and timeline.
  • Agree who makes the decision.
  • Shortlist vendors that meet your must-have requirements.
  • Score each vendor on a weighted scorecard covering features, integrations, usability, support, security and cost.
  • Agencies and executive search firms should add CRM and client management.
  • Test the finalists with a structured demo and a trial on real work.
  • Check security, compliance, references and contract terms.
  • Plan implementation, training and data migration before signing.

We assure you, buyers usually reach this decision for one of two reasons. Some teams are adopting an ATS for the first time to manage and automate their recruitment workflow. Others already use an ATS that no longer meets their needs. The steps below apply to both situations.

1. You want to smoothly manage and automate your recruitment workflow with an ATS.  

2. You’re already using an ATS that is not up to par, and you are unhappy with it, so you are finding the best ATS that fulfills your unique hiring needs.  

Whatever the reason is, you will get your answer to the most pressing question every user is struggling with, which is: How to find and buy the best ATS? 

Let’s not wait and dive deep into this practical step-by-step ATS buyers' guide.  

We assure you that at the end of this guide, you’ll know how to identify the best ATS. 

But Why Do You Need an Applicant Tracking System (ATS)?

The most important question, isn’t it?  

So, to address this question, you have to identify your organisation's hiring problem first. You have to figure out why the necessity arose in the first place.  

Here are some of the common reasons that trigger you to find the Best Applicant Tracking System (ATS) software solution. 

1. Increasing Hiring Obstacles & Needs 

As your company grows, your hiring needs will become more complex and extensive. To fulfil these hiring needs and accommodate growth, you need a scalable ATS that can scale with you.  

2. Inefficient and Traditional Workflow Management 

Without an ATS, recruiters and HR often find themselves buried under a mountain of emails and trapped in complex spreadsheets. This is not only time-consuming but also prone to human errors. 

In a scenario of missed opportunities, ATS emerges as a lifesaver, automating these hiring tasks and ensuring a more organised and efficient workflow. 

3. The Current ATS is Outdated  

Maybe your organisation uses an ATS, but it is unable to keep up with the latest hiring trends and strategies because it lacks modern features and functionalities. In this case, you need to look for an ATS that contains all the features that you need. 

4. Compliance and Data Security Concerns

What is the point if your current ATS fails to protect recruitment data and adhere to GDPR compliance? In that case, you need to look for a more secure option. 

How to Map Out Your Requirements for the Applicant Tracking System? 

Are you looking for an ATS that is perfectly suitable for you? 

If yes, then you will need to define your needs for the ATS accurately, but how?

Let’s check out how.   

1. Understand Your Recruitment Needs 

Your recruitment team needs to document your end-to-end recruitment process and mention the crucial activities recruiters must perform. 

Also, try to go the extra mile and consider future obstacles that might occur in conducting the entire recruitment workflow.   

But what’s the significance of doing this activity?  

It will help you identify exactly the recruitment needs that the new ATS software must fulfil.

2. Ask: What Your Current Solution Lacks?  

You are using an ATS, but it is not customisable to your needs or scalable as your hiring needs grow.  

Then, these are the red flags which you need to figure out based on the hiring needs you have identified.  

Make a checklist of what your needs are and what functionalities your current ATS is not offering.  

3. What is your recruitment budget?

Agree the budget with whoever approves spending, which may be a hiring manager, finance lead or business owner. Look beyond the subscription fee and estimate the total cost of ownership:

  • Subscription fees, which may be charged per user, per job or as a flat tier
  • Implementation and data migration charges
  • Training and onboarding
  • Integrations, additional storage and premium support
  • Contract length, renewal terms and price increases at renewal

Ask each vendor to quote the same scenario, such as ten users and a stated number of live jobs, so that prices can be compared fairly.

How to Plan Your Recruitment Budget for 2024?

 4. Define the Timeline for New ATS Implementation 

Get the timeline from your employer or hiring manager about when they need you to make the final decision about choosing the right ATS, and the time frame within which it should fully function. 

 This will help you take follow-ups accordingly. 

 5. Agree on Who Makes the Decision

Name the people who will use, approve and support the system before vendor conversations begin. Typical stakeholders include recruiters, hiring managers, the owner of recruitment technology, IT or security reviewers, finance and, where candidate data is concerned, legal or data protection leads.

Agree who has the final decision and how each group will score vendors, so that the scorecard below reflects shared priorities rather than one person’s preferences.

Key Considerations While Choosing an ATS 

There are certain criteria that you must assess before finalising an ATS. Here they are. 

1. Check out the Mobile Accessibility

Easily Accessible on Mobiles: You need to confirm that the ATS is mobile-friendly. This will give your recruiters and candidates the liberty to interact with the system anytime, anywhere.

Mobile Responsive Design: You should look for an ATS that has a mobile responsive design that adapts to different screen sizes and ensures a seamless experience on smartphones and tablets.

Mobile-friendly iSmartRecruit ATS 

2. Is the ATS Provider Offering Customisation?

Tailored Solutions: Check if you customise the ATS software to fit your unique hiring processes, needs, and workflows. 

Also, customisation options allow the system to adapt as your organisation grows and changes. 

3. Is the System able to integrate with Other HR Tools?

Seamless Workflow: Can your ATS be integrated with other HR tools like HRIS and payroll software to streamline your workflow, reducing manual data entry and errors? 

You can look for an ATS that acts as a central hub and integrates various aspects of HR management for efficiency and better data insights. 

Explore Top iSmartRecruit Integrations 

4. Assess Software Flexibility & Scalability

Adaptable Features: You must choose an ATS tool that offers flexible features and is capable of adjusting to your changing recruitment needs.

Growth Support: Ask your ATS vendor if the ATS can handle and manage an increasing volume of job postings and candidate applications as your company grows. 

5. Is the Software User-Friendly & Intuitive?

Ease of Use: If you choose an intuitive ATS, then it will reduce the learning curve for your team, and they can quickly adapt it. As a result, it enhances your team’s productivity from the start. 

Candidate Experience: A user-friendly system also improves the candidate experience, which positively impacts your employer brand.

6. Is Customer Support Prompt?

Quick Assistance to Your Query: Prompt and reliable customer support is very important to solve any issues you encounter with the system and minimise downtime. 

Support Channels: Review if the ATS provider offers multiple support channels (phone, email, chat) for their customer’s convenience.

7. Check out the Client’s Reviews

Real Experiences of Current Users: Client reviews give you information about real-world usage. Also, it highlights strengths and potential issues in the ATS system. 

You can reach out to them via email or social media to get more specifications related to their experience with the system.

 iSmartRecruit Client Reviews on Capterra 

8. Take a Demo and Run a Trial

Structured demo: Give each vendor the same short list of scenarios drawn from your real workflow, such as posting a job, parsing a resume, moving a candidate through stages and producing a report. Ask the vendor to show these in the live product rather than a prepared presentation.

Trial on real work: If a trial is available, run it on a live or recent role with the people who will use the system every day. Note where tasks take longer than expected.

Informed decision: Score each demo and trial on the scorecard below so that the decision rests on evidence rather than impressions.

9. How is the Vendor’s Reputation?

Industry Standing: A vendor with a good reputation is likely to offer a highly rated and reliable quality ATS.

Longevity and Expertise: Consider the vendor's experience and longevity in the current market as indicators of stability and continuous product improvement.

10. Evaluate Security & Compliance

Data Protection: You need to check whether the ATS complies with data protection regulations like GDPR and other labour laws in order to safeguard candidate information.

Security Measures: Choose the ATS if the vendor is offering robust security measures such as encryption and regular audits to protect against data breaches and malware activity. 

Regulatory guidance: Data protection rules apply to candidate data from the moment a vacancy is advertised until the data is deleted. In the UK, the Information Commissioner’s Office publishes guidance on recruitment and selection for employers and recruitment agencies under the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018. Ask vendors how the system supports consent, retention and deletion, and where candidate data is hosted. Take legal advice on the rules that apply in each country where you recruit.

Additional Checks for Recruitment Agencies and Executive Search Firms

Corporate hiring teams and agencies buy for different reasons. Agencies and executive search firms should also assess:

  • Client and contact management alongside candidate records
  • Job order and search project tracking across several clients
  • Candidate submissions to clients with clear status updates
  • Permissions that keep confidential searches and candidate details restricted
  • A recruiting CRM for long-term relationships with people who have not applied
  • Reporting by client, consultant and search

Top 10 Must-have Features in ATS Software You Can’t Miss

Are you confused by the many features ATS vendors offer? It can be overwhelming, right? But it doesn’t have to be that way. 

To get more clarity, check if they are offering the crucial features below or not. 

Resume Parsing

This feature will help you import resumes and automatically parse and extract key information from those resumes. It will save time, and no candidate will be overlooked. Plus, it turns a pile of resumes into a searchable database of talent in seconds. This way, resume management will be easier than ever. 

Candidate Tracking

Want to keep track of every candidate's journey through your hiring process? 

Then, this function helps you organise and manage every candidate efficiently. So you can run a smooth recruitment workflow.

Job Posting and Distribution

With a single click, you can easily post job openings to multiple job boards and social media channels. This expands your reach and effortlessly attracts a diverse pool of qualified candidates. Market your jobs in the most efficient way! 

Collaborative Hiring

Want to collaborate with team members to share feedback and make informed hiring decisions? This feature fosters a unified approach to evaluating candidates for a fit in terms of both skills and culture.

Interview Scheduling & Management 

Want to automate the interview scheduling and management to eliminate back-and-forth emails? 

Then, this tool is a must in an ATS to sync with calendars to make it easy to find the best time for both interviewers and candidates.

Communication Tools

Communication features help you maintain clear and consistent communication with candidates directly from the ATS. 

You can personalise recruiting emails and timely updates to enhance the candidate experience, reflecting positively on your employer brand image.

Reporting and Analytics

This feature allows you to gain insights into your hiring process with data-driven reports. It helps you understand what's working, where you can improve, and how to make more informed decisions.

Advanced Search and Filter Options

With this function in your ATS, you can quickly find candidates with the right skills using powerful search and filtering capabilities. It will allow you to sift through your talent pool with precision to identify top talent.

Automated Candidate Screening

Want to automate the candidate assessment process? 

Automatically screen candidates against predefined criteria such as skills, experience and education. This narrows the applicant pool to those who best match the role.

Review the screening rules for fairness and keep a person involved in decisions about who progresses.

Onboarding Integration 

You can streamline your onboarding workflow, a smooth transition from candidate to employee, with onboarding tools integrated into your ATS. 

AI Features

Many vendors now promote AI for matching, screening and communication. Ask what each feature does, what data it uses and how recruiters can review or override its output. Check whether the vendor tests for bias and whether AI scoring can be switched off. Keep a person involved in decisions about who progresses. Our guide to AI bias in hiring explains the risks to watch for.

 With this feature, you can prepare new hires for their roles before their start date, improving their initial experience and retention.

High-scalable and User-friendly iSmartRecruit ATS

55 Questions You Must Ask Your ATS Provider

We all know that selecting the right Applicant Tracking System (ATS) is crucial for streamlining your hiring process and enhancing candidate experience to ultimately secure top talent, right? 

 For that, you need to ask the right questions to ensure you choose an ATS that aligns with your organisation's specific needs. 

These 55 questions cover the main areas to check before buying. Use them in demos and written requests for information, ask every vendor the same questions and record the answers on your scorecard.

Industry Experience 

  • How long have you been providing ATS solutions?
  • Do you have clients with companies in our industry?
  • Can you share case studies or testimonials from similar clients?
  • How do you stay updated with recruitment trends and compliance regulations in our industry?
  • Are most of your customers large or small businesses?

Applicant Tracking System Features 

  • How does the system perform at our expected number of users and applications?
  • Is your ATS Mobile-friendly? 
  • Can I log in to your system on any computer using any browser?
  • Does your ATS come with a defined workflow or can I customise it as per needs?
  • What are the automation capabilities your system offers? 
  • Which AI or predictive features are included and how are they tested for bias?
  • What core functionalities does your ATS offer?

Integrations Capability 

  • Is there an API available for custom integrations?
  • Can your ATS integrate smoothly with our existing HR software and systems?
  • Is there support for calendar and email integrations?
  • How does the ATS handle integration with job boards and social media?
  • Can the system integrate with background check services and candidate screening?

Email Communication

  • Can we track email opens and interactions within the ATS? 
  • Does the ATS support email templates for candidate communication?
  • Is there an integrated email system, or will it work with our existing email provider?
  • How does the ATS ensure email deliverability and compliance with spam regulations?

Product Innovation 

  • Do you have a research and development team? 
  • How frequently do you release updates and new features? 
  • How do you incorporate customer feedback into your product development? 
  • Are there any upcoming features or innovations that we should be aware of?

Implementation 

  • What is your typical implementation timeline for the ATS?
  • Can you outline the implementation process and key milestones?
  • Who will be our main point of contact during the implementation?
  • What resources will be required from our side for a successful implementation?

User Training 

  • Will you provide training for our team on how to use the ATS?
  • What types of training materials and resources do you provide?
  • Is there an additional cost for training sessions?
  • How do you support new users after the initial training period?

Adding New Users 

  • What’s the limit to the number of users who can have access to your system?
  • Is it possible to add new seats as I need them? 
  • Can you tell us what the cost is of adding new users?
  • How do administrators add or remove users and manage permissions?

Data Security

  • Where is candidate data hosted and stored?
  • Who owns the client data? 
  • What precautions do you take to ensure the system is highly secure?
  • What’s your data protection policy? 
  • How often do you take backups?

Client Support 

  • What types of customer support do you offer (e.g phone, email, live chat)? 
  • What are your support hours, and do you offer 24/7 support? 
  • How do you handle urgent issues or system downtimes? 
  • Is there a dedicated account manager for our company? 
  • What is the average response time for support requests?

Pricing and Contracts

  • How is your pricing structured?
  • Are there any setup or implementation fees?
  • What is included in the base price, and what costs extra?
  • What are the terms of the contract, and is there a minimum commitment?
  • How does billing work for adding or removing users?

Final Considerations

  • Which of our requirements does your ATS not meet today?
  • Are there any upcoming changes or updates that we should be aware of?
  • How can we measure the success and ROI of implementing your ATS?

Why People Choose iSmartRecruit Over Other Applicant Tracking Systems?

The world of recruitment is fiercely competitive. 

So, choosing the right Applicant Tracking System (ATS) can be the difference between hiring success and missed opportunities, right? 

So, why iSmartRecruit? You must be wondering. Let’s find out why! 

iSmartRecruit stands out as the preferred choice for 10k+ recruitment professionals, hiring managers, HRs, and staffing agencies in 70+ countries. 

But why do so many choose iSmartRecruit over others?

1. User-Friendly Design

iSmartRecruit is celebrated for its intuitive user interface. We understand that your time is valuable, so our platform is designed to be learned quickly and used efficiently. 

It allows you to focus more on what you do best hiring top talent.

2. Advanced Features, Simplified

From AI-driven recruitment analytics to seamless integration capabilities, iSmartRecruit packs a powerful punch of advanced features. Yet, it's all presented in a way that's accessible and easy to use, regardless of your tech savviness.

3. Customisable to Your Needs

Recognising that no two recruitment processes are the same, iSmartRecruit offers unparalleled customisation. Tailor everything from workflow to communication templates, ensuring our system adapts to you, not the other way around.

4. Exceptional Support and Training

Our commitment to your success goes beyond recruitment software. iSmartRecruit provides comprehensive support and training resources, ensuring you maximise the benefits of your ATS investment.

5. Cost-Effective Solution

We believe in transparent, straightforward pricing without compromising on quality or functionality. iSmartRecruit delivers premium features at a cost-effective price point, making it an intelligent choice for organisations of all sizes.

6. Data Security and Compliance

In an era where data protection is paramount, iSmartRecruit ensures your candidate data is secure and your recruitment practices comply with global regulations.

Choosing the right ATS is a critical decision for your recruitment strategy. 

iSmartRecruit is here to make that choice easier with a platform that's powerful yet approachable, customisable, and backed by a team dedicated to your success.

Request a live demo of iSmartRecruit today, and see for yourself why so many recruitment professionals prefer our system.

So, are you ready to transform your recruitment process and achieve great hiring success? 

Conclusion

Choosing an ATS is easier when the process is structured. Define your requirements and agree who decides. Shortlist vendors, score them on the same criteria and test the finalists on real work. Check security and contract terms, then plan implementation before you sign. Use the scorecard and the 55 vendor questions in this ATS buyer’s guide to keep the comparison consistent.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is an ATS, and why is it important for recruitment?

An applicant tracking system (ATS) is software that helps organisations manage recruitment activities, from receiving applications to coordinating interviews and tracking hiring progress. Depending on the system, it can automate repetitive tasks, improve candidate management, support team collaboration and provide visibility into recruitment performance.

2. What features should I look for in an ATS?

Look for features that match your recruitment needs, including resume parsing, candidate tracking, job posting and distribution, interview scheduling, candidate communication, collaborative hiring, reporting and analytics, search and filtering, and onboarding integrations. Also evaluate HR system integrations, mobile accessibility, security and compliance controls. Recruitment agencies may additionally need CRM, client management and talent-pool features.

3. How do I choose the right ATS for my organisation?

Start by documenting your recruitment workflow, hiring volume, budget, implementation timeline and decision-makers. Separate must-have requirements from nice-to-have features, then shortlist vendors that meet your essential needs. Compare them using the same weighted scorecard, test finalists through demonstrations or trials, and verify security, compliance, contract terms, implementation support and data migration before making a decision.

4. What questions should I ask an ATS vendor before buying?

Ask vendors about essential features, customisation, integrations, security and data hosting, implementation timelines, training, customer support, pricing and contract terms. Also ask about data ownership, retention, export options and additional fees. Give each vendor the same questions and record the answers in your evaluation scorecard. Use a structured list of questions to ensure you cover the important details.

5. How is ATS pricing structured?

ATS pricing may be based on the number of users, job postings, recruitment volume or subscription plan. Additional charges may apply for implementation, data migration, training, integrations or extra storage. Request an itemised quote from each vendor using the same hiring scenario, and compare the total cost over the contract period, including renewal terms, potential price increases and cancellation fees.

6. How can an ATS help you identify and attract top talent?

An ATS can help recruiters distribute job postings across multiple channels, search existing candidate databases, organise talent pools and identify applicants whose qualifications match role requirements. Automated communication and interview coordination can also improve the candidate experience. However, an ATS supports rather than replaces recruiter judgement, proactive sourcing and human review of screening decisions

About the Author

author
Amit Ghodasara is the CEO of iSmartRecruit, leading the charge in HR technology. With years of experience in recruitment, he focuses on developing solutions that optimize the hiring process. Amit is passionate about empowering recruiters to achieve success with innovative, user-friendly software.

You can find Amit Ghodasara's on here.

Join Our Award-Winning AI Recruitment Software

Demos are a great, fast way to learn about iSmartRecruit.
Connect with us now to learn more!

30 minutes to explore the software.
ATS
play
30 minutes to explore the software.

Want to Hire Top Talent 3x Faster Like a Pro?

Use our easy-to-use ATS to automate and smoothly manage your end-to-end recruitment workflow.

Prompt copied to clipboard!